Saturday, May 4, 2019

Kharavela's Revenge - Ocean of Churn - Sanjeev Sanyal


We provide a summary of main points from Chapter 4 (Pages 63 - 81) of the book "Ocean of Churn" by Sanjeev Sanyal

Iron Age (1700 BC or earlier)

  • Advanced iron tools found in Indian subcontinent
  • Major highways
    • Uttar path (east - west): Afghanistan - Gangetic plain - Bengal
    • Dakshin path (north - south)

Lion kingdoms

  • Eastern Indians capable of sailing long distances (DNA evidence in Australia)
  • Kalinga kingdom (Orissa & neighbourhood) was epicentre of maritime boom
  • Many ancient paths along W mouth of Ganga & Chilika lake
  • Present day Sinhalese have part Bengali-Odiya origins
    • Mahavamsa (epic in Pali): genetic, linguistic, cultural evidence
    • Narasimha worshipped in Orissa; Lion is in Sri Lanka flag

Prized resources from India

  • Large contingent of Indian soldiers was part of Greek Imperial army (Ref: The Histories - Herodotus, 450 BDC)
  • India was famous for gold, cinnamon, horses
  • Phoenicians sailed around Africa (Cape of good hope) 2000 years before Vasco da Game

Alexander and War Elephants

  • Many Greek vs. Persian wars took place (Alexander vs. Darius 3)
    • Contingent of Indian cavalry fought till the end (stirrup was invented in India)
    • Army of Massaga (E Afghanistan) had 7000 Indian mercenaries, who were prisoners of war. Since they refused to fight their own countrymen, they were massacred by Alexander
    • Alexander defeated king of Pure tribe
    • Weary trips forced him to return home. He mistakenly sailed down the Indus and reached the Arabian Sea instead of the mouth of Nile
    • Few soldiers retired by sea. Bulk of his army died in deserts of Balochistan and E Iran

Mauryan Empire

  • Since NW India was politically unstable following Alexander’s incursion, Chandragupta Maurya and Chanakya conquered it easily
  • They defeated Seleucus Nikator and made him sign a treaty in 305 BDC. Mauryan territory extended all the way to Balochsitan, while Seleucus received 500 Indian was elephants and mahouts in exchange
  • Seleucus used these elephants to crush internal rebellion in Greece. Elephants became the symbol of Seleucid empire ! In coins, he was shown riding elephant drawn chariots !

Ashoka the Cruel

  • Chandragupta’s son Bindusara ruled for 25 years till 273 BC. His kingdom expended from Afghanistan to Bengal to most of Southern India
  • How Ashoka annexed the throne ?
    • After Bindusara dies in 274 BC, crown prince Sushima rushed back to Pataliputra from NW frontiers, Ashoka killed him at E gates
    • Took help of Greek mercenaries
    • Killed 99 half-brothers and hundreds of loyal officials in 4 year civil war
    • Crowned emperor in 270 BC
    • Known as Chandaashoka - Ashoka the Cruel
    • Ashoka converted to Buddhism one decade before Kalinga war (rebellious vassal). This had more to do with politics of succession than any regret for sufferings of war
    • Ironically, none of Ashoka’s inscriptions in Odisha talk about remorse of war. These are found in faraway places like NW Pakistan
    • Ashokvandana (Buddhist text) describes how Ashoka got many members of Jain and Ajivika sects killed. E.g. 18000 Ajivikas in Bengal in a single day
    • He was not a successful administrator. During his later years, the kingdom disintegrated. He brought disrepute to the vast Mauryan empire built by his grandfather and sustained by his father.
    • Post independence, academic historians built up the legend of Ashoka the Great to provide lineage of Nehru’s socialist project!!! Uncomfortable evidence was swept under the carpet.
    • Why should modern Indians accept a narrative based on minimal evidence?


Mauryan trade routes

  • Arthashasta written by Chanaklya (aka Kautilya)
  • Dakshin path was preferred trade route, esp. for diamonds found in peninsular India
  • Tamralipti in Bengal was a thriving port

Kharavela’s revenge

  • Ashoka’s successors (eg. Dashrath) tried to mend relations across sects
  • For Ajivikas, he constructed rock-cut shrines: Nagarjuni and Barabar caves in Gaya, Bihar
  • Kingdom broke up rapidly after Dashratha
  • Satavahanas took over Southern territories with capital at Pratishthana (Paithan, Maharashtra). —> this clan is never mentioned in textbooks
  • Kalinga rebelled under Chedi clan, with Kharavela as their military leader in 193 BC
  • He defeated Indo-Greek Demetrius at Magadh in 185 BC
  • He defeated last Mauryan king Bahasatimati in 181 BC and sacked the Mauryan capital
  • Kharavela’s inscriptions at Udayagiri hill overlook those of Ashoka at Dhauli. They mention that he defeated the Satavahanas, Mauryas, Indo-Greeks and Pandyas too.
  • He conducted Ashwamedh Yadnya and declared himself as Chakravarti (world conqueror) - most powerful ruler in Indian subcontinent at that time —> Kharavela is never mentioned in Indian textbooks, since historians emphasise continental over coastal perspective

No comments:

Post a Comment