Saturday, May 4, 2019

Introduction - Ocean of Churn - Sanjeev Sanyal

We provide a summary of Chapter 1 (Introduction) of the book "Ocean of Churn" by Sanjeev Sanyal.


An extraordinary event circa 730 AD

  • Pallava kingdom spanned Tamil Nadu, Andhra Pradesh, S Karnataka; it was very active commercially and culturally
  • Pallava king Parmeswara Varman II died without a direct heir
  • In capital city Kanchipuram, a grand assembly of scholars and chieftans deliberated for days
  • Finally they decided to reach out to a collateral branch of the dynasty that survived in a distant kingdom since five generations
  • After a tough & adventurous journey, the delegation reached the court of Hiranya Varman. His youngest son, aged 12, took up the offer.
  • The young prince was crowned Nandi Varman II in Kanchipuram
  • He defeated internal rivals & external enemies, ruled for 65 years and became one of the greatest monarchs in the history of southern India

Cross-cultural links

  • Close link between Pallavas and Cambodians is well known. Eg. Khmer script is derived directly from Pallavas
  • Pallava dynasty began with a marriage to a princess from a Naga or Serpent clan from across the seas
  • Multi-headed cobra was the symbol of Cambodian royalty from ancient times to present
  • Malaysia has Bhujang valley (bhujang = naga = snake)

Importance of Indian Ocean

  • Churn of people, goods and ideas along the Indian Ocean and its shores have defined human history from the very beginning
  • For example, Nalanda University in Bihar was partly funded by Sri Vijaya kings of Sumatra
  • India's geographical location, its cultural might and economic weight made it the pivot of Indian Ocean world
  • Between 16th and 18th centuries, Europeans dominated the Indian Ocean
  • In 19th century, the Atlantic Ocean began overshadowing the Indian Ocean
  • In 20th century, the Pacific rim rose in importance
  • In 21st century, the center of gravity is gradually shifting back to Indian Ocean

Ocean-centric perspective

  • Most histories of Asia provide a continental or land-centric perspective. Eg. Mauryan, Mughal, Mongol, Tang empires
  • History looks very different when viewed from coastlines rather than from an inland point of view. Eg. Chola, Majapahit, Omani kingdoms
  • With shift of perspective from land to sea, certain individuals become extraordinary
    • Odisha's Kharvela who ended the Mauryan empire
    • Marthanda Varma of Travancore who defeated the Dutch and ended their dreams of colonizing India
    • Nathaniel Courthope of East India Company who heroically held out against the Dutch at the Indonesian island of Run

Bias in most history books

  • Most books on history of Indian Ocean or maritime Spice Route were written from a Western point of view. 
  • They focused on developments after Europeans entered the scene
  • Worse, such histories "ended" when the Europeans left in the mid 20th century
  • A systematic bias in existing literature is the preference given to writers and sources from outside the Indian Ocean world
  • Local texts, inscriptions and oral histories are discounted as being inferior sources than the testimonies of foreign visitors and travellers who are assumed to have greater credibility !
  • Example: Chinese pilgrim-scholar Huien Tsang viewed the world exclusively from a Buddhist perspective
  • Writings of European visitors are often systematically biased against the Hindu and Islamic cultures that they encountered in India
  • Post 18th century narratives also contain an additional layer of racism
  • It is surprising how the Aryan Invasion Theory continues to survive, esp. among the elite in India. This despite the lack of any textual or archaeological support, and a plethora of genetic and other evidence against it

Philosophy of History

  • All narratives of history are based on some philosophical framework about the flow of events that allows the historian to make sense of it all
  • A popular way to explain history is to focus on heroic (or demonic) individuals whose actions and thoughts disproportionately influenced the course of history
  • Most history writing was financed directly or indirectly by "great men" who liked to highlight their own importance

Complex Adaptive System Theory

  • According to the author Sanjeev Sanyal, the world (and thus history) is a complex adaptive system (CAS)
  • It is a chaotic place where the flow of events is influenced by the constant and often unpredictable interactions between a host of factors and independent agents
  • Other examples of a CAS are ecological systems, financial markets, economies, English language, cities, weather, law and Hindu religion
  • Per Mark Twain, "History does not repeat itself, but it rhymes."

The Indian Soldier

  • A consistent continuity in history is the presence of Indian soldiers and mercenaries serving in faraway lands since ancient times
  • Among notable examples, Indian soldiers and mercenaries have
    • fought for Persians against Greeks
    • driven war elephants for Macedonian general Seleucus
    • fought for Sinhalese rulers in Sri Lanka
    • protected commercial interests of Tamil guilds in SE Asia
    • served British in Opium Wars in China and Boer Wars in S Africa
    • served across the globe during World Wars I and II

The Female Line

  • Matrilineal customs played a dominant role in the history of Indian Ocean rim
  • Matrilineal is different from matriarchal, which refers to societies where women are rulers/leaders as a matter of custom
  • Matrilineal societies mark lineage through the mother and female ancestors. Men still run the show, but the status of women tends to be higher than societies that are purely patrilineal/patriarchal. Eg. Queen's nephew can become future king
  • Examples of matrilineal societies along the Indian Ocean rim:
    • Nairs of Kerala
    • Bunts of Karnataka
    • Garo, Khasi and Jaintia tribes of Meghalaya
    • Karen of Myanmar
    • Minangkaban of W Sumatra
    • Cham of Vietnam

No comments:

Post a Comment